Can Social Media Hurt Your Personal Injury Case?

You made your accounts private and assume your posts are safe. In an Illinois injury case, the other side can still request relevant photos and messages, and deleting them can bring court penalties, so stop posting and keep everything.

Yes. Insurance adjusters and defense lawyers search Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok for photos, check-ins, and comments that make an injury look smaller than it is, and once a lawsuit is underway, Illinois court rules let the defense demand relevant posts and messages. A smiling photo from a family barbecue can become a trial exhibit. If you delete that photo, you create a second problem, because an Illinois judge can penalize a party who destroys evidence. Our Northbrook personal injury attorneys help injured people across Chicagoland protect their claims from the first day, including what they share online.

How Insurers Use Your Posts to Pay You Less

An insurance adjuster works for the company that pays your claim. The adjuster can read your public posts and compare them with your medical records.

An adjuster can use these kinds of posts against you:

  • Photos or videos of physical activity, such as lifting a child, dancing, hiking, or working out
  • Check-ins at restaurants, concerts, sporting events, or vacation spots
  • Captions such as “feeling better” or “back to normal,” even on a single good day
  • Comments about the accident, your injuries, or your case
  • Photos that friends or relatives post and tag you in

A single photo leaves out the pain medication you took before the party and the two days you spent in bed afterward. The adjuster uses the photo anyway, and the photo alone cannot show a jury what happened before or after it was taken.

Posts about the accident itself create a separate risk. Illinois follows a rule called modified comparative fault, which means a judge or jury can assign you a share of fault, and that share reduces or bars your recovery. If you are found 50% or less at fault, you still recover, minus your percentage of fault. If you are found more than 50% at fault, you recover nothing. A post that says “I only looked at my phone for a second” gives the defense a reason to move that percentage against you.

What the Other Side Can Request in an Illinois Lawsuit

Once a lawsuit is underway, both sides exchange evidence through a court-supervised process called discovery. Illinois Supreme Court Rule 201 (general discovery provisions) lets a party request any matter relevant to the case, including photographs, communications, and electronically stored information. Facebook posts, Instagram stories, TikTok videos, and private messages all fit that description.

Privacy settings control who can browse your profile. The discovery rules contain no exception for posts you marked private, so a private account still has to answer a proper request for relevant content.

Rule 201 also protects you from overbroad requests. A judge can limit or deny a request to prevent unreasonable annoyance, expense, embarrassment, or oppression, and can weigh whether the burden of producing electronic records outweighs their value to the case. When a defense lawyer demands your entire account history, your lawyer can ask the judge to narrow the request to material that relates to your injuries.

Why Deleting Posts Can Hurt Your Case

An Illinois judge can penalize you for deleting photos after an accident.

In Shimanovsky v. General Motors Corp., the Illinois Supreme Court held that a person who expects to be in a lawsuit must take reasonable steps to preserve relevant evidence. The court also held that a judge can penalize a party who destroyed evidence before the case was even filed.

Under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 219(c), a judge who finds that a party unreasonably failed to follow the discovery rules can, among other orders:

  • Order that party to pay the other side’s reasonable expenses and attorney fees caused by the violation
  • Bar a witness from testifying about the issue the missing evidence concerned
  • Strike part of that party’s pleadings
  • Dismiss the claim, which the Illinois Supreme Court treats as a last resort for a party who deliberately or without good reason disregarded the court’s authority

The judge weighs several factors before choosing a penalty, including the harm to the other side and whether the person acted in good faith. Screenshots, shares, and a friend’s copy of the same photo can stay online after you delete the original.

Best Practices While Your Injury Claim Is Open

The best practice is to stop using social media and secure all accounts until you receive legal advice. An attorney can discuss continuing to use social media while your claim is open if you follow a few rules. These steps protect your claim from the day of the accident until the case ends:

  • Stop posting about the accident, your injuries, your recovery, and your case.
  • Keep every existing post, photo, and message exactly as it is, and talk to your lawyer before you delete, edit, or archive anything.
  • Ask your lawyer before you change your privacy settings.
  • Ask friends and family not to tag you, check you in, or post photos of you.
  • Decline friend and follow requests from people you do not know.
  • Keep conversations about your case off group chats and direct messages.
  • Follow your doctor’s activity restrictions offline, too.

Give your lawyer a list of every account you use, including ones you rarely open. Your lawyer can then review what is already public and prepare for any discovery request before the defense sends one.

When Social Media Helps Your Case

Your lawyer can use the same discovery rules against the other side. Rule 201 covers evidence relevant to any party’s claim or defense, so your lawyer can request the at-fault driver’s posts, messages, and videos too.

After a car accident in Chicagoland, useful evidence can include a video the other driver posted from behind the wheel, a message admitting fault, or a check-in showing where the driver was before the crash. Your posts from before the accident can help as well. Photos of you coaching Little League or running a 5K show a jury what you could do before the injury.

Let your lawyer collect that evidence. Your lawyer knows how to preserve it and when to present it.

Talk With a Chicagoland Personal Injury Lawyer

If you are hurt and unsure what to do about your accounts, talk to us before you post or delete anything. An attorney personally handles your case, backed by more than 60 years of combined legal experience. We are available 24/7, offer free consultations, and serve clients in English and Spanish. Contact Stein & Shulman today. You pay no attorney fee unless we win.